[ntp:questions] ESR looking for good GPS clocks
Ron Frazier (NTP)
timekeepingntplist at c3energy.com
Tue Mar 6 15:22:39 UTC 2012
On 3/6/2012 4:45 AM, Rob wrote:
> unruh<unruh at invalid.ca> wrote:
>> He is suggesting that the on board gps chip have ntp on board, so that
>> your computer timestamps the request, the gps chip then timestamps when
>> that trequest was received and returns it. No gps chip that I know of
>> has an onboard ntp server. So if you want to get a chip fab to make you
>> a special purpose chip which contains a gps receiver and ntp onboard,
>> you could probably do it-- but it might cost a bit more than $100 ieach
>> lots of 100.
> Of course not. NTP is software, not hardware.
> The only thing you need is special firmware for any existing GPS chip
> that includes the NTP functionality you want, and maybe drops some other
> functionality to make room in the flash.
> Some manufacturers provide a software development kit that allows the
> user to write his own code, link that with the object modules written
> by the manufacturer, and create a new flash file for the GPS device.
> At least SiRF provides such a development kit to its commercial customers.
I haven't been following this thread extremely closely, but I did read
ESR's blog post and exchanged a few emails with him. He says SIRF GPS's
exhibit a "wobble" of variance of outputting the NMEA time of 170 ms or
so. I've personally observed with my USB BU-353 this effect, where the
Meinberg Server Monitor shows my computer locked into the GPS time
within a few ms and a number of internet servers that I have programmed
will show offsets of say 50 ms. However, when I originally set the
fudge factor, I had almost all the internet servers showing single digit
offsets when the PC is locked to the GPS time. Sometimes, it shows a
positive offset for the internet servers and sometimes it shows
negative. Anyway, ESR says SIRF GPS's aren't suitable for timekeeping.
I have not done anything to corroborate his statement, other than
observing this strange behavior. I'm going to start a new thread
talking about what I've seen in more detail, since it's really a
different topic. I just mentioned it since you brought up SIRF.
(PS - If you email me and don't get a quick response, don't be concerned.
I get about 300 emails per day from alternate energy mailing lists and
such. I don't always see new messages very quickly. If you need a
reply and have not heard from me in 1 - 2 weeks, send your message again.)
timekeepingdude AT c3energy.com
More information about the questions