[ntp:questions] any reason why NTP client would receive -10sec diff?
david at ex.djwhome.demon.co.uk.invalid
Tue Nov 11 07:47:34 UTC 2008
Blair Smith wrote:
+ limited time as an NTP admin!! Naturally their ntpd wasn't going to
+ accept a jump by -10sec, so subsequently their server started polled our
A normal, out of the box, ntpd would step, if all sources agreed on the
error. However, it is most unlikely that this is ntpd.
+ tier-one server every second for a while before giving up, after which
A real ntpd cannot be configured to poll that fast, and such a fast
polling rate would be considered abusive. Do you,by any chance, have
kiss of death enabled on your server, as that polling rate would trigger
it. I believe one of the tactics it uses to try and dissuade abusive
clients is to report a false time to them. A non-standard (or
non-recent) implementation might not recognize the other signals that it
had received the kiss.
> Their software using NTP was something called "Netware", which I'm
+ not familiar with, so I was unable to help them. One potential cause of
I didn't realise people still used this. I thought Microsoft CIFS/SMB
networking now completely dominated the market. When I last encountered
it, Netware was a file server that ran as a DOS extender; it used to be
the dominant corporate file server software in the days of MS-DOS, and
the early days of Windows. Although clients can time synchronize to
this, it is only the server that I would imagine would try to use NTP.
+ problems at our end was a lightening strike at our facility on Friday
+ 7th Nov, which affected other systems in the same building but not, as
+ far as I know, the clocks or NTP servers. The client started reporting
+ this problem on that Friday evening, but that could be just a coincidence.
More information about the questions