[ntp:questions] How bad is USB?

Richard B. Gilbert rgilbert88 at comcast.net
Fri May 1 13:29:31 UTC 2009


David J Taylor wrote:
> Richard B. Gilbert wrote:
> []
>> You can try it and see what happens!  The results may be sufficiently
>> good for your purposes.  You will almost certainly not get microsecond
>> accuracy.  If you are willing to settle for +/- 10 milliseconds you
>> can almost certainly get that.
>>  There are (at least) two groups of people who hang out here:
>> a. The "chimeheads" in pursuit of the "one true time", and
>> b. The "synchs" who don't really care what time it is as long as all
>> their machines have the SAME time.
>>
>> Both groups use the same tool, NTPD.  It turns out that having a
>> stable and accurate source of time makes it much easier to get a
>> whole herd of machines to agree on what time it is.
> 
> Richard,
> 
> Yes, I /could/ try it, but I was rather hoping that someone else already 
> had.  I also think that it will be somewhere between 1 microsecond and 
> 10 milliseconds, but just where?
> 
> I'm in a third category (probably) - as long as my PCs "sound" to have 
> the same time, I'm happy.  Actually, I want UTC as well, but as I have a 
> speaking clock working on two PCs it's "nice" when they both speak at 
> the same time.  I wonder how close that needs to be - a few 
> milliseconds, perhaps?  Here's what I actually get - all with Windows.
> 
>  http://www.satsignal.eu/mrtg/daily_ntp.html
> 
> - within about 250 microseconds on my serial/PPS ref-clock PCs
> - within about 2 milliseconds on my "Synced from ref-clock" PCs
> - within about 25 milliseconds on my Vista PC.
> 
> Yes, I used to get better on the ref-clock PCs when running FreeBSD, but 
> I've since been able to shut down that PC and just use a Windows box 
> instead.  It's good enough for me.
> 
> Cheers,
> David

I have not tried to use USB devices as time sources.  The conventional 
wisdom here says "don't"!  If I already had such a device I'd try it. 
Given the conventional wisdom that USB is not suitable I'm not going to 
waste my money or my time.  YMMV!




More information about the questions mailing list